$2,099,900
Community
Port McNicoll Real Estate
Tay, Simcoe
44Active
132Sold
9Leased
Port McNicoll Market
Updated Aug 23, 2026
Homes
Median sale price
$490K
Median PSF (est.)▼ 34.9%
$331/sqft
Price trend
Sold last 90 days
11
Active listings
30
Months of inventory
5.0
Avg days on market
25
Sale-to-list ratio
96.58%
Absorption rate
20.0%
Market Insights
Investor mix — estimated proxy (90d)
Investor-proxy share: 0.00% · End-user: 100.00% (from 11 sales, 0 leases)
Price reductions (90d)
Price-reduction rate: 9.09%
Avg reduction: $75,000 (12.50%)
Monthly reduction trend
2024-10: 0.0% (7 listings)
2024-11: 0.0% (5 listings)
2024-12: 0.0% (5 listings)
2025-02: 20.0% (5 listings) · avg $34,100
2025-03: 0.0% (3 listings)
2025-04: 0.0% (4 listings)
2025-06: 0.0% (5 listings)
2025-07: 0.0% (5 listings)
2025-08: 0.0% (5 listings)
2025-09: 25.0% (4 listings) · avg $14,000
2025-10: 25.0% (4 listings) · avg $24,900
2025-11: 66.7% (3 listings) · avg $60,000
2025-12: 0.0% (3 listings)
2026-01: 0.0% (4 listings)
2026-03: 0.0% (4 listings)
2026-04: 0.0% (3 listings)
2026-05: 0.0% (3 listings)
2026-06: 0.0% (4 listings)
2026-08: 20.0% (5 listings) · avg $75,000
Re-entries (past 12 months)
Re-entries: 7 of 85 sold · rate 8.24%
Avg price change: +$2,143 (+0.37%)
Median PSF (est.) vs parent area
Median PSF: $331 — -30.88% vs municipality avg ($479)[discount]
Seasonality (annual pattern)
Historically strongest months: Jan, Jul, Aug
Historically weakest months: Mar, Feb, Nov
Annual averages: DOM 27.1d · sale-to-list 96.58% (n=85)
Monthly detail
Jan · 4 sales · DOM 12.3d · STL 94.90%
Feb · 7 sales · DOM 40.6d · STL 97.16%
Mar · 7 sales · DOM 30.0d · STL 96.00%
Apr · 7 sales · DOM 27.6d · STL 95.81%
May · 3 sales · DOM 20.0d · STL 99.72%
Jun · 9 sales · DOM 28.0d · STL 96.97%
Jul · 6 sales · DOM 13.8d · STL 97.75%
Aug · 10 sales · DOM 17.5d · STL 98.70%
Sep · 5 sales · DOM 26.2d · STL 94.49%
Oct · 11 sales · DOM 25.4d · STL 97.51%
Nov · 8 sales · DOM 48.1d · STL 93.26%
Dec · 8 sales · DOM 25.8d · STL 96.33%
Loading market intelligence…
About Port McNicoll Real Estate
Explore 44 active listings in Port McNicoll, located in Tay. compare 43 properties for sale and 1 for lease, and find your next home with detailed market data and price estimates.
Port McNicoll has seen 141 completed transactions recently, with 132 sold and 9 leased properties providing rich comparable data for accurate valuations.























